As the FBI investigates the Smith crew following the museum robbery, Hope continues to be skeptical of Bobby's true whereabouts that night, suspecting that his salesman job is a sham and that he was somehow involved in the Pittsburgh heist. Meanwhile, Annie and Tom's relationship is rekindled when she asks Tom and Jeff to join her on a side job that involves identity theft. Despite his wariness of Annie, Jeff agrees to take part in the crime. And Joe is forced to lie to Shawn's widow, Macy (recurring guest star VALARIE RAE MILLER), when she continues to press him for the truth about Shawn's disappearance.